CAN A BIG AGE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN
TWO PEOPLE HURT THE RELATIONSHIP?
Storyline:
I’m in love with a great guy
who happens to be fifteen years older than I am—I’m Twenty-one and he’s Thirty-six.
He’s been married and divorced and has children not much younger than me. My
family thinks I’m making a big mistake, and have come right out and told me
that they don’t approve of the relationship. Am I being naive to think our age
differences don’t matter?
Yes, you’re naive if you think your
age differences don’t matter. They do, but so do all the other differences in
your circumstances and personalities. So ignoring this issue, or any issue, won’t
work. The more you insist that there aren’t any problems, the more you are
probably suppressing your concerns for fear that they will sabotage the
relationship. Both you and your partner need to honestly and directly face and
discuss all the various problems that have or could emerge around your age
difference.
Significant age differences between
partners can cause serious problems in relationships. The word “significant” is important here: If your partner is
four or five years older or younger, it won’t make much of a difference.
However, if your partner is ten or more years older or younger than you, it can
cause difficulties depending on your ages and other aspects of your
personalities. I’ve found that age differences mean less as both partners
get older. For instance, a fifteen-year age difference between a
thirty-five-year-old man and a twenty-year-old woman will probably create more
potential hazards than that age span in a sixty-five-year-old man and a
fifty-year-old woman. The age difference will affect the first couple more,
since their maturity and experience levels are usually much more dissimilar
than the second couple’s.
Here are the most common issues
couples face when there is an age difference:
IF YOU ARE THE OLDER PARTNER:
1. You can
become impatient with your mate.
If you are significantly older than
your mate, you may lose patience with her level of immaturity, lack of life
experience, and learning process. This will be especially true if your mate
is between twenty and thirty years of age. After all, you’ve already gone
through a lot of what she’s dealing with; you’ve realized it’s not the end of
the world when you go through a crisis, because it always works out in the end;
you’ve made mistakes and figured out how to do things the right way. So it’s not
easy watching your younger partner stumble through these same life experiences.
2. You
have a tendency to act like a parent to your mate.
When you have ten, twenty, or
thirty more years of life experience than your partner has, you will find it
next to impossible not to offer advice, correct, and direct him or her.
After all, you’ve been through this
before—you know the best way to do it. Of course your intentions are loving;
you’re only trying to help. But the effect can be very destructive to your relationship.
YOU BEGIN ACTING LIKE A PARENT AND TREATING YOUR PARTNER LIKE A CHILD. Naturally,
your mate feels as if you don’t trust her, you don’t respect her, and responds
just like a rebellious teenager would—she becomes resentful and pulls away. And
this parent-child game will quickly destroy the
passion in your sex life, since your relationship starts taking on incestuous
overtones.
3. You may
be much more financially successful than your partner.
Most older partners have more
financial stability, and therefore more power in the relationship. You’ve had
many more years to build up your income, purchase property and possessions,
etc. This financial superiority can create tension between you and your partner
in numerous ways—you may feel resentful about being the one who provides more,
especially if you are a woman; you may feel like you should make the important
decisions (what to spend, where to live, what kind of vacation to take) because
it’s your money, and your partner might not feel this is fair. You may have
difficulty lowering your standards of living to accommodate your mate’s.
4. You may
be tempted to control your partner because you hold more of the power in the
relationship.
All of the warning signs above add
up to this one—it’s easy when you are much older than your partner to get into
a power trip and become controlling. You have more money, success, experience
and therefore it’s tempting to “pull rank” on your mate.
5. You may
be tempted to compromise or sacrifice your interests, friends, and activities
in order to appear more compatible with your partner.
If your mate is much younger, you
may give up interests he or she doesn’t appreciate and take on habits that make
you appear younger.
If you’re involved with a much
younger person, here are some questions to ask yourself:
“Do I
respect my partner?”
“Am I proud
of my partner?”
“Do I trust
my partner?”
“What am I
learning from my partner?”

IF YOU ARE THE YOUNGER PARTNER:
1. You may
put your partner on a pedestal and give up your power.
If your mate is much older than you
are, he or she is probably more successful, experienced, and financially
secure. This may influence you into unconsciously feeling your partner is
“better” than you are, and tempt you to idealize him rather than see him for
who he really is. When you allow yourself to feel lesser because of your
mate’s chronological advantage, you give up your power. You take his advice
rather than trusting your own; you blindly believe his criticisms of you rather
than questioning whether or not he’s correct; you invalidate your own needs and
feelings out of deference to your partner. You tell yourself:
“He’s the one who’s paying for it,
so we’ll do it his way.” “I’m sure he knows what he’s doing. After all, look
how successful he is.”
“He knows much more about these
things than I do because he’s older.”
Even if your partner doesn’t want
to play this role with you, you may be tempted to fall into this pattern simply
because of the age difference. And if your partner happens to enjoy his role as
the older, wiser one, or actually uses it to control you, watch out—your
relationship won’t be very healthy.
2. You may set your partner up
to be like a parent.
Another consequence of being the
less experienced, less worldly one in a relationship is that you may be tempted
to recreate a parent/child dynamic with your partner. If you are always
asking his advice, counting on him to help you, depending on him for money,
using his connections to your advantage, allowing him to make decisions for
you, you are, in essence, behaving like a child and giving him the
authority to be your father (or if you’re the younger man, your mother). This
prevents you from truly growing up and opens the door for all kinds of
emotional programming to run itself out.
Even when your partner doesn’t
control you, you may feel controlled and intimidated just by virtue of
the fact that he or she is that much older. You may react by becoming
rebellious, withdrawn, or difficult. Perhaps this is the relationship you had with
your own parents, or you may be acting out the anger you never had the courage
to express to them when you were growing up.
3. You may be tempted to
compromise or sacrifice your interests, friends, and activities in order to
appear more compatible with your partner.
If you are involved with a much
older person, here are some questions to ask yourself:
“Does my
partner respect me?”
“Does my
partner treat me as an equal?”
“Do I feel
like an equal with my partner?”
In your case, there are two other
issues you and your boyfriend must discuss: First, whether or not you
want children and expect him to start a second family; and how you both plan to
deal with your respective families (your parents, his children).
So that’s what to watch out for.
Now, the good news—a relationship between two people of very different ages can
work if both partners avoid falling into the patterns we’ve just talked
about by being aware of them, communicating about their feelings, and making
agreements that help create an equal and respectful relationship. The more
you have in common and the more committed you are to working on the
relationship, the better your chances for survival.